portable

How specific can you be in a field report without crossing the line?

28 posts in this topic

By 'specific' I mean about the girl's appearance. I just had a really pointless experience with a girl and she's inspired me to log onto the main site in order to write my first (negative) report.

I wanted to mention that she seemed to have loads of tiny little bruises across her bum like flea bites? I don't want to come across as a total prick though! Do you think it's worth mentioning? Or would that be going over-board?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally I would say that this is what the report system is all about, it can't all be good reports.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A lot of people pay little attention to a report that is only report submitted by a contributor, whether they are positive or negative.

If a flea bitten arse bothered you maybe you should mention it. More importantly were you stratching the next day?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

True. I also wanted to mention her hygiene. It was okay, but when we were done she just sprayed her lady bits with a bit of deoderant and put her knickers back on. I'm glad I was the first guy to see her that day. :( Would mentioning that be crossing a line do you think?

And I'm sure there was a guy who wasn't a punter in the flat aswell who she was talking to while I was getting dressed. :)

:D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A lot of people pay little attention to a report that is only report submitted by a contributor, whether they are positive or negative.

If a flea bitten arse bothered you maybe you should mention it. More importantly were you stratching the next day?

The agency she works for offers a review service. She said to leave her a 'five start review'. Nope. No I won't, sorry. I'm probably not going to use the agency again so I might submit a 2 star review, and since they do actually leave a couple of bad reviews on the girls' profiles I hope it'll stay there to be honest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Generally, if a detail was important to you, then it will probably be of interest to at least some (if not all) other readers.

My advice is to keep the report impersonal. With negative FRs, I always find it best to wait a couple of days before submitting. It's also best to proofread the report many times before submitting asking yourself whether it comes across as objective rather than vindictive (hint, you are aiming for the former :)). FWIW, I think that the marks you mention are worth recording, but remember that you have no real idea what the girl did hygiene wise after you left (she may have had a long soak in the bath), so in my view it's best not to speculate on her state of cleanliness for the next punter, even if you are probably right.

Mention the guy in the property if you like, but did that really materially affect your punt one way or another ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Generally, if a detail was important to you, then it will probably be of interest to at least some (if not all) other readers.

My advice is to keep the report impersonal. With negative FRs, I always find it best to wait a couple of days before submitting. It's also best to proofread the report many times before submitting asking yourself whether it comes across as objective rather than vindictive (hint, you are aiming for the former :D). FWIW, I think that the marks you mention are worth recording, but remember that you have no real idea what the girl did hygiene wise after you left (she may have had a long soak in the bath), so in my view it's best not to speculate on her state of cleanliness for the next punter, even if you are probably right.

Mention the guy in the property if you like, but did that really materially affect your punt one way or another ?

Yeah, I definitely don't want to be petty or vindictive in anyway. I think it's just that on the agencies site, and the reviews are of the 5 star "most awesome lass EVAR" variety so I want to make an honest review :)

You're right about the hygiene issue. Good point.

As for the guy... she works for an agency in a rented apartment so I'm guessing he should't have been there? And there was another girl there in the next room who left at some point. No idea what's going on there of if to mention it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
As for the guy... she works for an agency in a rented apartment so I'm guessing he should't have been there?

Is it against the escort agency code of practise for another male to be in a property used for prostitution then :)? You have no way of knowing whether he should have been there or not (unless the girl told you he shouldn't have been). He might have been the next punter (unlikely), her boyfriend (vaguely possible), her pimp (possible), a maintenance man fixing something (possible) or the on-site security (possible) amongst many other things. I know why you raise it as it can be an unsettling feeling having strangers about, but implying that he shouldn't be there is simply a guess.

And there was another girl there in the next room who left at some point. No idea what's going on there of if to mention it?

Again, was it a problem? Most likely there is more than one girl who works from that property and it was her you heard leaving (perhaps she had finished her shift or simply was popping out for a break). My favourite incall agency nearly always has two girls working from a two bedroom flat at the same time.

My advice is to concentrate on what made the punt unsatisfactory for you rather than look for potential red herrings just to add weight to the negative FR.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My advice is to concentrate on what made the punt unsatisfactory for you rather than look for potential red herrings just to add weight to the negative FR.

Good point.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm glad I was the first guy to see her that day.

It is possible that you were the first punter to see her that day, however ........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wanted to mention that she seemed to have loads of tiny little bruises across her bum like flea bites?

Could be as a result of liposuction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It is possible that you were the first punter to see her that day, however ........

I have no idea if he was her boyfriend, if he had been with the girl in the next room or what, but unless her first appointment of the day was in and out in about 10 minutes then...:)

Could be as a result of liposuction.

Nah. If not she should get her money back. She had er...rather plump booty. In a good way of course. :D Besides, they were more across the small of her back/bum.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nah. If not she should get her money back. She had er...rather plump booty. In a good way of course. :) Besides, they were more across the small of her back/bum.

Maybe she is a porn star and has just finished filming Debbie does Porcupines.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They even lied about her name then! Whatever next? :)

Anyway, report has been done and I even left a review on the website.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have no idea if he was her boyfriend, if he had been with the girl in the next room or what, but unless her first appointment of the day was in and out in about 10 minutes then...:)

IIRC a Kinsey study done some few years ago came up with a figure of 7 minutes for the average time taken from intromission to ejaculation for the human male, allowing 1 minute for "there, there, is that better now?" etc. that leaves just about 2 minutes for her to spray her bits, on average.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tough one.

I had a punt a few weeks ago where there were many unsavoury things about the lady.

Do I report these? If I do, might she take offence and try to expose me, which would be pretty awfull.

What I might do is post her privately, but that doesn't help the rest of you.

Whilst some reviews are probably over egged, I suspect that many bad punts are not reported.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just be honest in FRs, balanced ones are to be preferred as generally no punts are totally crap and no punts are totally fine.

For example, a lady might have stupendous and well formed breasts, be no beauty in anyone's book and have major stretch marks on a saggy stomach plus a lousy attitude.

If you know what flea bites look like, which I don't, then say they "looked just like flea bites", if not then just say "a lot of odd looking small bruises on the lower back and bum".

If she was not the lady in the pictures then that needs saying.

If she was described as a beauty and in fact looked like the north end of a south bound cow then we need to know that too but there are better ways of saying that than I just used.

In short, "tell it like it is" without trying to be insulting and you will be fine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anything related to poor hygene should be stated, as this is a big concern for many punters. She would be unlikley to have a quick deodorant spray if she intended to have a proper wash immediately afterwards.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always tell it as it is - good or bad - I did have one girl who found my login name (which was the same on another site) and started abusing me via e-mails - it must have affected her business :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im generally quite detailed in my FR's because I also prefer Fr's which provide as much info as poss.....it helps me when Im researching a wg to check if she is fits the criteria Im looking for etc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In short, "tell it like it is" without trying to be insulting and you will be fine.

My thoughts exactly. If she reads it and isn't happy then that's not my problem, I'm only being honest and I'm certainly not out to "get her" or insult her. Maybe she'll learn something from it rather than being stroppy but I doubt it. ;)

The best time's I've had with escorts, even for just half hour visits has been when they've had a positive attitude. I saw one girl who's routine was a little transparent, but she was engaging and enthusiastic even though it was the first time I'd met her, and just for half an hour, but I still think about her and would probably see her again.

All I need is to meet a cute curvy girl with epic boobs with that attitude and I'd be fine! And broke.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My thoughts exactly. If she reads it and isn't happy then that's not my problem, I'm only being honest and I'm certainly not out to "get her" or insult her. Maybe she'll learn something from it rather than being stroppy but I doubt it. ;)

The best time's I've had with escorts, even for just half hour visits has been when they've had a positive attitude. I saw one girl who's routine was a little transparent, but she was engaging and enthusiastic even though it was the first time I'd met her, and just for half an hour, but I still think about her and would probably see her again.

All I need is to meet a cute curvy girl with epic boobs with that attitude and I'd be fine! And broke.

Whatever you do don't visit Indian Delight in Docklands then!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did a review for the escort i see,she loved it and said she had a lot of good feedback from it.I didn't go into too much detail about are sexual time together,too much of a gentlemen for that,but i did say enough about her looks,personality,appearance and apartment that would interest another punter to book her.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see that after Portable report there are two new negative reports were posted on the same girl last week.

http://www.punternet.com/frs/fr_view.php?recnum=100149

http://www.punternet.com/frs/fr_view.php?recnum=100182

Both of the above meeting happened more then a month ago. I only asume that not many guys would post negative report, unless they read previous negative reports submitted by somebody else? When its happened, they are jumping on the bandwagon, to declare that something similar occurs to them during the meeting.

Why they not submit Fr straight away? Do they need some kind of assurance, that he was not the only one, who had less then satisfactory experience with a particulat WG?

I suppose the same applies for the positive reports also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see that after Portable report there are two new negative reports were posted on the same girl last week.

http://www.punternet.com/frs/fr_view.php?recnum=100149

http://www.punternet.com/frs/fr_view.php?recnum=100182

Both of the above meeting happened more then a month ago. I only asume that not many guys would post negative report, unless they read previous negative reports submitted by somebody else? When its happened, they are jumping on the bandwagon, to declare that something similar occurs to them during the meeting.

Why they not submit Fr straight away? Do they need some kind of assurance, that he was not the only one, who had less then satisfactory experience with a particulat WG?

I suppose the same applies for the positive reports also.

Supersleuth, both first time reporters submitted on the first day for bookings as you say over a month before, looks very suss to me!

S x

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now