pollyp23

Race: Limiting Your Choice On Your Profile: Legality

113 posts in this topic

I wrote a report on here about a meeting and, as is required, listed the SPs phone number.

 

She is now getting 'hundreds' of calls from Asian men, none of whom intend to book.

 

I' suggested that she, like quite a few others, limit her punters to none Black/Asian punters (and remove her FR).

 

She asked about the legality of this.

 

Is this racial discimination?

 

Is a provider of personal services allowed to list and refuse to see people of certain characteristics, be they age, height, religion or colour?

 

Thought?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

probably illegal under the discrimination legislation.  But dunno how a banned person would seek redress because prostitution contracts are deemed imoral and therefore unenforceable in law. He would also need a real name and address to put on a county court summons.  You cant issue a summons to 'fatslappertracey', you need a real name.

Also, I cant see a court forcing a woman to have sex with someone she didnt want to. I suspect her rights on this would trump the discrimination rights.

Anyway, if she doesnt want to see a cartain type of man, why would a man of that type want to see her. She would clearly not give a good service in those circumstances.

 

Edit. if having her phone number on the FR is such a pain she could ask Galahad to put her on the no reports list, which would remove the FR.

Edited by Coventrypunter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
probably illegal under the discrimination legislation.  But dunno how a banned person would seek rederss because prostitution contracts are deemed imoral and therefore unenforceable in law. He would also need a real name and address to put on a county court summons.  You cant issue a summons to 'fatslappertracey', you need a real name.

Also, I cant see a court forcing a woman to have sex with someone she didnt want to. I suspect her rights on this would trump the discrimination rights.

Anyway, if she doesnt want to see a cartain type of man, why would a man of thay type want to see her. She would clearly not give a good service in those circumstances.

'fatslappertracey' versus pollyp23. Wonderful!

 

Good point your last paragraph.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
'fatslappertracey' versus pollyp23. Wonderful!

 

Good point your last paragraph.

 

sorry. edited my post but you posted before I saved it....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
probably illegal under the discrimination legislation.  But dunno how a banned person would seek redress because prostitution contracts are deemed imoral and therefore unenforceable in law. He would also need a real name and address to put on a county court summons.  You cant issue a summons to 'fatslappertracey', you need a real name.

Also, I cant see a court forcing a woman to have sex with someone she didnt want to. I suspect her rights on this would trump the discrimination rights.

Anyway, if she doesnt want to see a cartain type of man, why would a man of that type want to see her. She would clearly not give a good service in those circumstances.

 

Edit. if having her phone number on the FR is such a pain she could ask Galahad to put her on the no reports list, which would remove the FR.

Thanks, I can ask to have it removed: I've done this before under similar circumstances, its a thought though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quite a few profiles on AW state racial preferences. This may be illega, but in view of the dubious morality of prostitution I very much doubt that any action would be taken.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quite a few profiles on AW state racial preferences. This may be illega, but in view of the dubious morality of prostitution I very much doubt that any action would be taken.

The Ladies worry is that AW may ban her for infringing a rule.

 

Its impossible to talk to anyone on there about policy, its all FAQs, none of which seem to cover this.

 

THere are alos profiles that give age limits (ageist), those that won't see disabled clients, those that won't see overweight clients and I once saw one that was heightist!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not being funny but as a service provider ladies will get phonecalls from lots of blokes whatever colour, yes and some will have no intention of making a booking this is part and parcel of being an escort with your phonenumber published. I presume her phonenumber is in the public domain anyway as an s.p?

If she is so concerned she should ask Galahad to remove the report or her number. Sorry but putting 'won;t see asians or blacks' on her profile will not stop guys ringing..she is assuming when people use her number they will read the whole profile and lets be honest alot don't!Also some will ring anyway and how does she know what race they are on the phone?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Not being funny but as a service provider ladies will get phonecalls from lots of blokes whatever colour, yes and some will have no intention of making a booking this is part and parcel of being an escort with your phonenumber published. I presume her phonenumber is in the public domain anyway as an s.p?

If she is so concerned she should ask Galahad to remove the report or her number. Sorry but putting 'won;t see asians or blacks' on her profile will not stop guys ringing..she is assuming when people use her number they will read the whole profile and lets be honest alot don't!Also some will ring anyway and how does she know what race they are on the phone?

All very true.

 

I suppose there is some protection on AW in that one can ask punters to e-mail you first.

 

I wonder if Galahad would consider having no phone numbers, but a link to AW? I somehow doubt it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Racial discrimination is fairly common on AW - many women bar Asian and or black men. Funny, they never state they won't see white men. That must because no white man has ever been a timewaster, nutter or no show. *rolls eyes*

 

She may also want to consider that by putting No Asian/Black men on her profile will show her up for the racist she is and put off men who don't like this kind of behaviour.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Racial discrimination is fairly common on AW - many women bar Asian and or black men. Funny, they never state they won't see white men. That must because no white man has ever been a timewaster, nutter or no show. *rolls eyes*

 

She may also want to consider that by putting No Asian/Black men on her profile will show her up for the racist she is and put off men who don't like this kind of behaviour.

The problem then comes though that she gets harrassment by guys who are insulted that she won't see them because of their colour. It read to me that its not that she doesnt want to see guys of that ethnicity but that the ones who are calling are just being time wasters. So how do you stop a time waster. They come in a all colours and creeds. I guess by email only on aw, but unless someone states their ethnicity on their message and profile you dont know what colour someone is from their email. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is the main issue with the wg in question, that she doesn't want her time wasted by people who won't turn up, or that she doesn't want to see asian clients whether genuine or not?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The problem then comes though that she gets harrassment by guys who are insulted that she won't see them because of their colour. It read to me that its not that she doesnt want to see guys of that ethnicity but that the ones who are calling are just being time wasters. So how do you stop a time waster. They come in a all colours and creeds. I guess by email only on aw, but unless someone states their ethnicity on their message and profile you dont know what colour someone is from their email. 

Yes, there is that too Chloe. As an escort you have to put up with the idiots and timewasters calling and wheedle them out by their attitude on the phone when they book. By barring any ethic group/race/nationality/etc she could miss out on some lovely gents who don't fit into the racial stereotype she has created. 

 

Apart from that- what is Asian- anyone from the entire of Asian- Japanese, Chinese, Indonesian etc etc. And does it just cover someone who was actually born in those countries, or anyone who has a drop of non white blood or is 3rd generation British Black. Does she require a full family tree and history before she sees them?

 

The secret is to be prejudiced against twattery not colour. 

 

PS: Chloe, aren't you meant to be shopping?!

Edited by MinxyLydia

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
She may also want to consider that by putting No Asian/Black men on her profile will show her up for the racist she is and put off men who don't like this kind of behaviour.

That's how I see it. I can understand that some ladies might prefer not to meet guys from other races, but that shows them up as racists and I prefer not to see them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Excuse my ignarance but this debate is a bit O.T.T.  We choose what / who we would like to see should the working girl have the same choise to see a punter or not ?.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

'The secret is to be prejudiced against twattery, not colour'! I may have to steal that for my signature.

 

I find the OP, or the situation described therein, to be devoid of logic. If the woman doesn't want to see Asian men ( whatever that means as pointed out above by Lydia) but at the same time says the people ringing at the moment are Asian and have no intention of booking, I don't see what the problem is. 

Perhaps she should say she doesn't want phonecalls from anyone born on the continent of Asia, or whose forebears were born there? Given that 4 billion people live in Asia and millions more of Asian descent live elsewhere, I'd say it should cut down on the calls. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wrote a report on here about a meeting and, as is required, listed the SPs phone number.

 

She is now getting 'hundreds' of calls from Asian men, none of whom intend to book.

 

I' suggested that she, like quite a few others, limit her punters to none Black/Asian punters (and remove her FR).

 

She asked about the legality of this.

 

Is this racial discimination?

 

Is a provider of personal services allowed to list and refuse to see people of certain characteristics, be they age, height, religion or colour?

 

Thought?

 

It is not illegal. In countries where prostitution is legal, the WG may refuse having sex with you. One of the regulations. And 

she does not have to state any reason whatsoever. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The secret is to be prejudiced against twattery not colour. 

She'd probably end up with hardly any clients at all then :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think its up to the lady to decide who she does and doesnt see.

I'd always book a white woman over a black woman and I am NOT racist, I just prefer white woman sexually thats all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Moved this to General Discussion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmm

Mebbe since the FR went up, she has been inundated with TW calls from asian men,  apart from saying no asians how would people suggest she stops this timewasting?

 

Taking her phone number off her profile will mean she gets a lot less clients cos many will ignore profiles not showing a number.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hmm

Mebbe since the FR went up, she has been inundated with TW calls from asian men,  apart from saying no asians how would people suggest she stops this timewasting?

 

Taking her phone number off her profile will mean she gets a lot less clients cos many will ignore profiles not showing a number.

I'm just bloody relieved I live in a predominantly white British area. It means i don't get any calls from timewasters at all, ever. None, nope, not one. I know those who called at 3 and 4 am this morning were just lovely chaps who happen to be early risers. 

 

Sorry, was distracted then by some pigs flying past my window. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I fail to see the correlation between Asian men and timewasters.  Where I worked there is a very large Asian population and they made up a large proportion of my clients but I didn't have a problem with that at all.  There are TW's in most cultures IMHE

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm confused who were talking about? but I would rather she just said no Asians / Blacks etc on her ad if she doesn't want to see non-whites etc.

 

Least that way people will know not to call or brother her.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wrote a report on here about a meeting and, as is required, listed the SPs phone number. She is now getting 'hundreds' of calls from Asian men, none of whom intend to book. 

Thought?

So, solely as a result of your FR on Pnet, she is getting "hundreds" of calls from "asian" men all of whom are timewasters?

Perhaps she needs to look at her profile on AW and consider if it needs amending in some way. I think I'll take this "hundreds of calls from asian timewasters" with a pinch of salt. In fact I think I see the same flying pigs that Sarita saw just going past my window.

Thought? It's all very well being nice and kindhearted but it's her life and she's the one who should be dealing with it not you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.