Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Maze

Dubious Frs

22 posts in this topic

OK I'm not going to name names or make accusations but I'm sure you've all looked at the FR's of certain posters and wondered if there really to good to be true. You know the kind of thing I mean, they only ever punt at the same establishment(s), the ladies concerned always look better than their pics and the whole thing reads like the script of a porno movie, some FR's are about as believable as Arthurian legend - if you catch my drift lol.

 

Well should Punternet and other review sites be a little more rigorous in discerning the authenticity of reviews so their not hijacked by SP's who simply turn them into another form of advertising, and do you think you've been mislead by a dodgy review.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Opens jumbo bag of popcorn...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If there is incontrovertible evidence of dishonest FR activity then I will delete the reports and put the lady/establishment on the No-Reports list. Mere suspicion, however, is not sufficient for me to take that action. As the OP indicated, savvy FR readers can easily spot dodgy patterns, and playing silly FR games ultimately does the service providers involved more harm than good. So, I will always try to err on the side of leaving the reports online and let you all make up your own minds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have had a negative FR removed on occasion because the lady 'retired', but in reality probably moved onto another unknown establishment. It now looks like I've only had positive experiences at the various establishments I've punted at and the establishment has got a NO off it's books.

 

The lack of a neutral option on the recommendation has led me to say YES to some mid-range punts. Rarely are punts totally black or white, so I do try to err on the side of leniency but some of my reservations will be tactfully mentioned in the text for the benefit of the reader.

 

Maybe once the OP has had more opportunity to write his own FRs, he will understand some of the dilemmas involved.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No one knows if the OP has written none, few or lots as his FR name may be different (like mine is).

 

If he is as new as his Forum details suggest then point is valid as I know how awful my FRs are when I am not fully in the mood to take the time to write the report fully and only adhering to the rules others in the useless other thread decry.

 

A new fave has said thanks for such a nice report, but I re-read it and felt I had not done her justice in a short and not well expressed report.

 

I am guilty of praising most of the time because I usually don't choose to write about poor punts (MY choice, don't get me started) and I do find that SPs seem to treat me very well compared to some people's experiences with the same ones (but not as good as some stud monkeys with other SPs).

 

Other Frs to compare SP on and other sources too these days.

 

Why is this in MK forum?

Edited by vivluvsme

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why is this in MK forum?

I would hazzard a guess that its because he is referring to milton keynes field reports or he is based here so automatically posted in here..just a guess. The OP should make himself clearer.

Edited by Chloe Kisses

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I take the content of FRs with a grain of salt. FRs seem to be like you said, a platform most punters use for delusions of grandeur and fantasies.

Edited by Sekine

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I take the content of FRs with a grain of salt. FRs seem to be like you said, a platform most punters use for delusions of grandeur and fantasies.

 

I would have said, with respect, that that's a definite exaggeration from my reading of them and my pre or post reading of FRs for the SPs I have booked with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reason I chose the MK section is simply because of the large number of FR's written about it's establishments, moving away from the point for a moment why does MK seem to have so many knocking shops and indies, is it demographics, does MK have a higher number of sad middle age divorced guys like me who have to pay for sex because no one will do it with them for free. The reason I asked the original question was because I find it hard to believe that there are some posters who never seem to have a bad punt and that makes me suspicious. I've been doing this for six years or so since the

previously mentioned divorce and for the most part it's been great fun and I'm extremely grateful to all the lovely ladies who've taken good care of me, there are some ladies I've seen as many as twenty times but even when your seeing a lady you know well it's still possible to have a less than satisfactory experience because she's just having a bad day at the office. At the end of last year I went along to see a young lady by the name of Alisa in London, with around 180 mostly positive comments in her feedback she's well on her way to becoming an AW superstar and I thought it was a sure thing but I was very disappointed with our meeting, it was clear she was in a bit of a rush and I just didn't get the level of service I'd expected, why does that kind of thing never seem to happen to certain Punternet contributors.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reason I chose the MK section is simply because of the large number of FR's written about it's establishments, moving away from the point for a moment why does MK seem to have so many knocking shops and indies, is it demographics, does MK have a higher number of sad middle age divorced guys like me who have to pay for sex because no one will do it with them for free. The reason I asked the original question was because I find it hard to believe that there are some posters who never seem to have a bad punt and that makes me suspicious. I've been doing this for six years or so since the

previously mentioned divorce and for the most part it's been great fun and I'm extremely grateful to all the lovely ladies who've taken good care of me, there are some ladies I've seen as many as twenty times but even when your seeing a lady you know well it's still possible to have a less than satisfactory experience because she's just having a bad day at the office. At the end of last year I went along to see a young lady by the name of Alisa in London, with around 180 mostly positive comments in her feedback she's well on her way to becoming an AW superstar and I thought it was a sure thing but I was very disappointed with our meeting, it was clear she was in a bit of a rush and I just didn't get the level of service I'd expected, why does that kind of thing never seem to happen to certain Punternet contributors.

Okay.

 

1) There are not actually that many establishments in MK and only a few of them have reviews ever done on them. If you look in the MK papers there are some establishments that you wouldnt have ever heard of it you handnt looked in the paper as they have a zero online presence and in all these years I havnt seen a review done on some of them.

 

2) Some guys do not leave negative reviews preferring only to leave a review if he had a good experience. There are guys out there who are the opposite, seeing no reason whatsoever to leave a good review and prefering instead to use the system to only warn of bad experiences. Maybe the posters you are refering to fall into the first category.

 

3) If you going on number of reviews then its still confusing as to why you posted this in the MK section when Central London and Manchester have a far higher number and if you read those you will see the same names of establishments coming up time and time again.

 

4) There are not actually that many indies based in MK as such. If you look at the local section you will see they are in several locations around Buckinghamshire. Sometimes there are a good number of ladies in there but only me , autumn, helen, candykink and a blonde whos name i cannot remember are actually listed as milton keynes. There are others of course, mkbonnie, but I never read past the local section. The paper adds a few more names too, someone called Catherine etc

 

5) The girl with the high feedback. Did you check to see if she is a cammer, if so then the majority of her feedback could be from camming and not escorting. 

 

6) I think this sort of thing does happen to other posters but they maybe cross check the girls they see with other sites such as capt 69, punternet, oldestprof etc to see a cross section of information on the girl and dont just rely on aw feedback for their info. Perhaps it was something to do with you that caused her to want to rush throught your booking, perhaps not, just saying

Edited by Chloe Kisses

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quite.

 

And with the 30 day (?) restriction on repeat reports, there are hardly going to be a load of false FRs.

 

Unlike AW! I for one am the author of the only three reports on one Lady and I can assure readers that they are genuine and all within a three week period, but they just might have been false.

If there is incontrovertible evidence of dishonest FR activity then I will delete the reports and put the lady/establishment on the No-Reports list. Mere suspicion, however, is not sufficient for me to take that action. As the OP indicated, savvy FR readers can easily spot dodgy patterns, and playing silly FR games ultimately does the service providers involved more harm than good. So, I will always try to err on the side of leaving the reports online and let you all make up your own minds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why is this in MK forum?

 

Good point - moved.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No one knows if the OP has written none, few or lots as his FR name may be different (like mine is).

 

This raises an interesting point: why is it that people are allowed to use one name for the FR section, and another here on the forum? Why, for that matter, would anyone choose to do it? It strikes me as a bit odd - surely it would make more sense to use the same name in both sections, as many do. Then, for example, if a poster here makes a comment about a girl - either negative or positive - and then follows it up with a FR, we would know it's the same person, rather than having the misleading impression of two people saying similar things about her. In other words, greater clarity.

 

If for any reason this query is out of order, my apologies. Likewise, vivluvsme, absolutely no offence is intended to you personally, or to anyone else for that matter. I just find it slightly puzzling, so I thought I'd ask.

Edited by Beauregard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This raises an interesting point: why is it that people are allowed to use one name for the FR section, and another here on the forum? Why, for that matter, would anyone choose to do it? It strikes me as a bit odd - surely it would make more sense to use the same name in both sections, as many do. Then, for example, if a poster here makes a comment about a girl - either negative or positive - and then follows it up with a FR, we would know it's the same person, rather than having the misleading impression of two people saying similar things about her. In other words, greater clarity.

 

If for any reason this query is out of order, my apologies. Likewise, vivluvsme, absolutely no offence is intended to you personally, or to anyone else for that matter. I just find it slightly puzzling, so I thought I'd ask.

Its a reasonable question, I expect it as the two sections are virtually different websites. Facebook is even worse: I've got two profiles, one the real me, the other (not Pollyp BTW), for chatting to my Ladies under their real persona. This might seem a bit one sided and it is, but it brings a sense of reality to them and we don't talk about punting in public.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This raises an interesting point: why is it that people are allowed to use one name for the FR section, and another here on the forum? Why, for that matter, would anyone choose to do it? It strikes me as a bit odd - surely it would make more sense to use the same name in both sections, as many do. Then, for example, if a poster here makes a comment about a girl - either negative or positive - and then follows it up with a FR, we would know it's the same person, rather than having the misleading impression of two people saying similar things about her. In other words, greater clarity.

 

If for any reason this query is out of order, my apologies. Likewise, vivluvsme, absolutely no offence is intended to you personally, or to anyone else for that matter. I just find it slightly puzzling, so I thought I'd ask.

Because registration for the forum is separate to registration for the forum - they are not linked. Some people want to contribute to the forum, some don't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Because registration for the forum is separate to registration for the forum - they are not linked. Some people want to contribute to the forum, some don't.

 

Thanks for the response. In fact, to clarify: I had guessed that it's not technically possible to prevent it, but there are plenty of things in the rules - e.g. touting, trolling, posting messages all in caps - that are technically possible but prohibited, and my question was more along those lines.

Edited by Beauregard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This raises an interesting point: why is it that people are allowed to use one name for the FR section, and another here on the forum? Why, for that matter, would anyone choose to do it? It strikes me as a bit odd - surely it would make more sense to use the same name in both sections, as many do. Then, for example, if a poster here makes a comment about a girl - either negative or positive - and then follows it up with a FR, we would know it's the same person, rather than having the misleading impression of two people saying similar things about her. In other words, greater clarity.

 

If for any reason this query is out of order, my apologies. Likewise, vivluvsme, absolutely no offence is intended to you personally, or to anyone else for that matter. I just find it slightly puzzling, so I thought I'd ask.

Apart from just wishing to have separate names on each i know one punter on here who couldnt use his nick on here on the FR section as it was already taken by someone else, but that FR author wasnt a member on here using that nick obviously.

 

Some punters dont wish to report negative punts is a reason to answer the OP, entirely up to them of course. One long time punter on here said he wouldnt report a negative punt as it would make him look stupid he thought in front of other punters on here.

 

I have seen many what i would class as dubious FRs, but i couldnt prove they were, its just my opinion. Personally i only believe FRs by punters i know, trust and/or respect, but appreciate punters have to do their first one at some time. I stopped doing FRs for a number of reasons one being i didnt agree with the rules anymore, but its Galahads site so his rules which i do and always have accepted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes I can see now that some punters simply don't write FR's about their negative experiences and Chloe your right the lady I spoke about in London is also a cammer and I don't want to discourage anyone from seeing her; the point I was making was that even when everything about a ladies profile is genuine even her reviews and feedback you can still have a crap punt, yes it might just of been me I'm not exactly God's gift to women, it's just that I had been so looking forward to seeing her it was all a bit of a let down. As for the high profile of MK when it comes to FR's well it does come third on the list behind London and Birmingham but it's certainly not the third most populous place in the UK, it could lay claim to being our nations punting Capital.

On a positive note I hope to go and see the beautiful Sara at HoD on Thursday (if they don't change the schedule again) I know I'll enjoy that. I think that when she returns to South America she'll probably ask me to go with her and will spend the rest of our lives in some remote but beautiful part of the Andes raising llamas and alpacas and shagging. I'm not being delusional am I, be honest. I feel another topic coming on - WG'S YOUV'E FALLEN HEAD OVER HEELS FOR, do the ladies ever develop silly schoolgirl crushes on their clients or has the job just confirmed your belief that all men are bastards.

Edited by Vin DaLoo
Removed AW Profile Name (New Member)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This raises an interesting point: why is it that people are allowed to use one name for the FR section, and another here on the forum? Why, for that matter, would anyone choose to do it? It strikes me as a bit odd - surely it would make more sense to use the same name in both sections, as many do. Then, for example, if a poster here makes a comment about a girl - either negative or positive - and then follows it up with a FR, we would know it's the same person, rather than having the misleading impression of two people saying similar things about her. In other words, greater clarity.

 

If for any reason this query is out of order, my apologies. Likewise, vivluvsme, absolutely no offence is intended to you personally, or to anyone else for that matter. I just find it slightly puzzling, so I thought I'd ask.

In my case,i left the FR under my AW tag which is what i made the booking under.It's a name i've used for a few years now and was an old nickname of mine in rl.That also prevents the,"i've never seen them" which may arise.I think a few probably do that.

If the question becomes why havent they used that name on here.Some probably wouldnt like anything that could link to closely to their real identity,or maybe most/the best versions of the name there after was no longer available anymore having being long taken.It could also just be theyve used the name closest to the email address they used.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This raises an interesting point: why is it that people are allowed to use one name for the FR section, and another here on the forum? Why, for that matter, would anyone choose to do it? It strikes me as a bit odd - surely it would make more sense to use the same name in both sections, as many do. Then, for example, if a poster here makes a comment about a girl - either negative or positive - and then follows it up with a FR, we would know it's the same person, rather than having the misleading impression of two people saying similar things about her. In other words, greater clarity.

 

If for any reason this query is out of order, my apologies. Likewise, vivluvsme, absolutely no offence is intended to you personally, or to anyone else for that matter. I just find it slightly puzzling, so I thought I'd ask.

I used to use the same name for FRs and the forum but got a little fed up with having my FRs brought up for discussion when I was in the chatroom, especially if they related to SPs who post here. I would prefer to be able to write FRs freely and honestly and let them stand by themselves.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The message board was off air for some years and when it came back i just felt like a change of name - I could so I did.

 

If anyone wanted to, they could probably match up with some of my comments on here with FRs.

 

I just typed who I was but then decided I quite like the split personality so i will leave things as they are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Because registration for the forum is separate to registration for the forum - they are not linked. Some people want to contribute to the forum, some don't.

 

We know what you meant :)

 

(and sorry for not being so gracious as the previous quoter to ignore it - or not to notice...).

Edited by vivluvsme

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0