sexpert

can you trust a FR by a one time reporter?

30 posts in this topic

I know that everyone has to do their 1st report at sometime, but why only ever do the one. If im interested in a girl and see a FR for her i obviously read it, then i click to see other reports from the author, if there are no more i dont trust it as much. One girl has had 4 negative reports in a month, her only reports, then all of a sudden its the best punt ever by a 1 time reporter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends how it is written and the content, you can usually read between the lines and work out f it was a genuine negative experience or if it was a Fake FR to diss an establishment / girl.

But if nothing else it raises the concern and punters should proceed with caution, and that is not a bad thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't spend too much time on frs.

Too many fr's is too much information.

Few only means the punters (the majority no doubt) don't use these boards and don't care to share information.

A solo fr is suspicious but then I wouldn't base any kind of impression on less than several.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I know that everyone has to do their 1st report at sometime, but why only ever do the one. If im interested in a girl and see a FR for her i obviously read it, then i click to see other reports from the author, if there are no more i dont trust it as much. One girl has had 4 negative reports in a month, her only reports, then all of a sudden its the best punt ever by a 1 time reporter.

Perhaps he's like a character in the play Sailor Beware. "Cup of coffee?" "Tried it once, didn't like it." "A smoke then?" "Tried it once, didn't like it." "I take it Marilyn's your only child?"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I know that everyone has to do their 1st report at sometime, but why only ever do the one. If im interested in a girl and see a FR for her i obviously read it, then i click to see other reports from the author, if there are no more i dont trust it as much. One girl has had 4 negative reports in a month, her only reports, then all of a sudden its the best punt ever by a 1 time reporter.

The scenario you mention in your last sentence would make me very suspicious. 4 negatives in a month is some going, as long as the 4 who have done the negatives have done more than one FR themselves and they are not years apart i would have no reason not to believe them over the first timers positive. However, if the 4 negative authors havent done any themselves i would think it might be malicious reporting, but i wouldnt punt with the lady personally anyway.

Overall, i appreciate FR posters have to start somewhere but unless i know them or at least have seen them post on here and think they seem genuine, i dont trust them, my trust would take a number of FRs to get or a combination of FRs and posts on here, and i am only interested in FRs that give me the information i require, were the services advertised actually offered and did the lady match her physical description and ideally information about her attitude and enthusiasm. FRs that say; i wont go into any detail or similar are of absolutely no use or interest to me.:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Point taken! I'd lurked for quite a while, never posting, and then was blown off my feet by one particularly wonderful lady. Felt obliged to tell the world how fabulous she is.

My first post was attacked. My bona fides was attacked. All because my FR said (unsurprisingly) "The lady is fabulous. I won't go into details, but she gives everything described on her site, and more." which was pretty well what all her other FRs have said.

I too am suspicious of a first and only FR. Unless you are desperate to see this lady or one other before you have the "op" and it all ends, wait a month or so, and if he doesn't report on another, dismiss him as a TW!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The scenario you mention in your last sentence would make me very suspicious. 4 negatives in a month is some going, as long as the 4 who have done the negatives have done more than one FR themselves and they are not years apart i would have no reason not to believe them over the first timers positive. However, if the 4 negative authors havent done any themselves i would think it might be malicious reporting, but i wouldnt punt with the lady personally anyway.

Overall, i appreciate FR posters have to start somewhere but unless i know them or at least have seen them post on here and think they seem genuine, i dont trust them, my trust would take a number of FRs to get or a combination of FRs and posts on here, and i am only interested in FRs that give me the information i require, were the services advertised actually offered and did the lady match her physical description and ideally information about her attitude and enthusiasm. FRs that say; i wont go into any detail or similar are of absolutely no use or interest to me.:)

good point Smiths, ive checked the 4 negative reporters and only 1 of them has done more than 1 report

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FRs that say; i wont go into any detail or similar are of absolutely no use or interest to me.:)

They are of no use to anyone and it really makes me wonder why the writer bothered in the first place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
good point Smiths, ive checked the 4 negative reporters and only 1 of them has done more than 1 report

In that case i wouldnt trust those 3 either, and i find it even more suspicious 3 first timers have posted a negative on that one lady in the space of a month. She is either unusually terrible or something else is going on. Smells fishy to me.:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have only one FR posted on Punternet. It was for a lady I had seen a number of times who has had positive Fr's from other punters.

She is my regular and on the odd occasion I have visited other ladies I have decided to stick with what I know and haven't bothered to shop around.

My one and only FR is a true and accurate account. The lady in question has read it and thanked me. My experience of the lady has been consistent over many months.

Does this mean that my one FR is not reliable or helpful to others?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have only one FR posted on Punternet. It was for a lady I had seen a number of times who has had positive Fr's from other punters.

She is my regular and on the odd occasion I have visited other ladies I have decided to stick with what I know and haven't bothered to shop around.

My one and only FR is a true and accurate account. The lady in question has read it and thanked me. My experience of the lady has been consistent over many months.

Does this mean that my one FR is not reliable or helpful to others?

The big difference is the lady has other positives from other punters, so for me i am not reliant on just one FR.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go by your first instinct and if you think the report is dodgy then don't believe......

Like most things in life you have to start somewhere but always go with your gut instinct....:eek:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have only one FR posted on Punternet. It was for a lady I had seen a number of times who has had positive Fr's from other punters.

She is my regular and on the odd occasion I have visited other ladies I have decided to stick with what I know and haven't bothered to shop around.

My one and only FR is a true and accurate account. The lady in question has read it and thanked me. My experience of the lady has been consistent over many months.

Does this mean that my one FR is not reliable or helpful to others?

It depends what it says and if people believe it, post a link to it and you may get an answer to yoru question.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Everyone decide for him/herself.

one time reporters ?

woman with many 1-timer reports ?

reporter with many good reports on same agency ?

Like in real-world PR, the possibilities are endless.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Everybody starts somewhere so that one time FR reporter could turn into a serial reporter :eek: but i think if a lady only has one review from one client who has never written a review before some may see it as a fake, but then again some people are broader minded. If the lady has more reports from other reviewers then obviously its more encouraging if they are from known reiviewers but again this really can be looked upon in a few angles as I also know ladies who prefer people don't write reports on them and also clients who won't see ladies with loads of reports so whose right and whose wrong!!!! Jeez who knows gang but if you wanna write reports or read them then you do just that and happy naughty encounters to you all.

Hugs Casey xx

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have only one FR posted on Punternet. It was for a lady I had seen a number of times who has had positive Fr's from other punters.

She is my regular and on the odd occasion I have visited other ladies I have decided to stick with what I know and haven't bothered to shop around.

My one and only FR is a true and accurate account. The lady in question has read it and thanked me. My experience of the lady has been consistent over many months.

Does this mean that my one FR is not reliable or helpful to others?

Good answer.

I think that sums up what a lot of one-time FR reports are. Genuine.

I get sick of the arrogance shown by some on here who assume that one-time reports are a waste of time.

Some maybe are. But maybe some reports from some serial reporters are too; a name to keep up? Does a girl perform differently for a name?

As someone else says reports come in all shapes and sizes and soem of the most sincere are those from the one-time reporter who has been lucky enough to find the girl who fits his bill. Some of them are written from the heart, whereas many serial reporters seem to write to a formula.

The best girls have a mix of both.

Frankly, I'm as suspicious of some of the serial reports as the one-times.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think that sums up what a lot of one-time FR reports are. Genuine.

I get sick of the arrogance shown by some on here who assume that one-time reports are a waste of time.

For me, a lot depends on how the report is written, regardless of the number of reports have been written by the reviwer. If the report is written objectively and covers what happens in a articulate way then I am inclined to believe it. What I mean is, as long as it isn't a bitch about how shit it all was without any explanation as to why it was, then I generally take them as sincere.

Good answer.

Some maybe are. But maybe some reports from some serial reporters are too; a name to keep up? Does a girl perform differently for a name?

As someone else says reports come in all shapes and sizes and soem of the most sincere are those from the one-time reporter who has been lucky enough to find the girl who fits his bill. Some of them are written from the heart, whereas many serial reporters seem to write to a formula.

The best girls have a mix of both.

Frankly, I'm as suspicious of some of the serial reports as the one-times.

A name to keep up? I don't think writing FRs makes you famous. I guess only WGs can answer whether they put more effort in if they know they are going to be reviewed.

I have written a number of field reports and they follow a similar style. The "formula" as you put it is to cover the services offered, what I experienced and whether I liked it. Surely thats what people want to read about.

I guess I could be like one of those idiots who says he had a great time, she's the best, lifetime experience, etc .... but he won't tell you anything about it. Not slating first time posters but a good few are like that.

If you use the FR system then I think you should put back in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Everybody starts somewhere so that one time FR reporter could turn into a serial reporter :) but i think if a lady only has one review from one client who has never written a review before some may see it as a fake, but then again some people are broader minded.

You make a good point but patterns do inevitably emerge. I'm thinking of WGs who have numerous reports written by one-timers, with every single one of them more than just glowing. Could just be a coincidence, but you'd think guys with large lumps of cash to spend on a single punt, a decidedly lyrical style of writing, and the time to post a FR in the first place, would most likely be repeating the experience with other WGs, no?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You make a good point but patterns do inevitably emerge. I'm thinking of WGs who have numerous reports written by one-timers, with every single one of them more than just glowing. Could just be a coincidence, but you'd think guys with large lumps of cash to spend on a single punt, a decidedly lyrical style of writing, and the time to post a FR in the first place, would most likely be repeating the experience with other WGs, no?

You may have a point about 'patterns'

But the 'lyrical poster'?

Not necesarily. That lyrical poster may find a girl he wants to stay with and not bother trying to find anyone else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You may have a point about 'patterns'

But the 'lyrical poster'?

Not necesarily. That lyrical poster may find a girl he wants to stay with and not bother trying to find anyone else.

So you reckon that a punter can blow in out of nowhere, sign up to be a field reporter for Punternet (not something done in 30 seconds), file a one-time This Was The Most Brilliant Experience Imaginable type of report including details of how easy it is to make a booking, how her apartment was fabulous, money well spent etc etc, and then disappear, never to be seen again?

Er, OK then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So you reckon that a punter can blow in out of nowhere, sign up to be a field reporter for Punternet (not something done in 30 seconds), file a one-time This Was The Most Brilliant Experience Imaginable type of report including details of how easy it is to make a booking, how her apartment was fabulous, money well spent etc etc, and then disappear, never to be seen again?

Er, OK then.

Well why not?

I agree that if a girl has a lot of FRs like that yes it is suss.

But if you trawl through the lists of those with a fair number of FRs many ill have FRs from 'serial poster' and at the ame time will have oneoffs from guys who aren't so interested in the variety aspect.

Punting takes many forms and I think sometimes we tend to forget that what suits us doesn't suit others.

I come somewhere just above the one time FR writer - 4 FRs, I think, plus some that have disappeared for various reasons, and that is purely because I tend to stick with one girl.

If I'd found her before some of the other FRs then I would be one of those one-time FRs you distrust.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The big difference is the lady has other positives from other punters, so for me i am not reliant on just one FR.

I submitted one FR on the 24th December 1999 when the rules were less rigid. I have recently had 2 FRs rejected. The first was for Barbie who was away for some time ill. She asked me to submit an FR so that her legion of admirers would know that she was available again. The second was recently for a delightful lady in N Wales who has only just taken up escorting to supplement her reduced income because of the credit crunch. She did not know of P'net and was pleased that she could get publicity through an FR. However as she is independent and does not have a website, that was probably why my FR failed. I have contacted the Administrator because it appears that the site has me as not submitting a single FR. I have visited many WGs in the last few years but have not reported on them beacause of their multiple reports.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's another one: http://www.punternet.com/frs/fr_view.php?recnum=97802

Not saying it's made up, but here's a guy who's blown in out of nowhere, visits a girl who also doesn't have any FRs either, and then appears to have an almost transcendental experience. It's a FR that would put even the fluffiest of punters in the shade.

'Delectable'. 'Beautifully presented apartment'. 'Soft and yielding lips' etc etc. Anyone know any heterosexual men who would actually write stuff like that? I don't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So you reckon that a punter can blow in out of nowhere, sign up to be a field reporter for Punternet (not something done in 30 seconds), file a one-time This Was The Most Brilliant Experience Imaginable type of report including details of how easy it is to make a booking, how her apartment was fabulous, money well spent etc etc, and then disappear, never to be seen again?

Er, OK then.

I have a few FR's by first time reviewers - all genuine reviews, and my last FR is by a first time PN reviewer but in the realm of cyberspace he has written a few more - he just happens to be Scandanavian and is unlucky enough to have been stuck seeing me for the last few years when he visits Aberdeen and doesn't punt in any other UK city.

The only reason he submitted an FR was because I asked him to (my last one before that was May 2008 so felt I would like another one). I just don't seem to get clients who are the FR type.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Here's another one: http://www.punternet.com/frs/fr_view.php?recnum=97802

Not saying it's made up, but here's a guy who's blown in out of nowhere, visits a girl who also doesn't have any FRs either, and then appears to have an almost transcendental experience. It's a FR that would put even the fluffiest of punters in the shade.

'Delectable'. 'Beautifully presented apartment'. 'Soft and yielding lips' etc etc. Anyone know any heterosexual men who would actually write stuff like that? I don't.

I noticed that one. Interesting that he mentions the views from the apartment when the girl has images on her website that show some of the views :eek:

I take all first time FR's with a pinch of salt, they won't influence me either way, unless the girl has stacks of them. In which case they can have a negative affect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now