RobinBanks

Field Report Query

21 posts in this topic

Apologies if this has been covered or is stated and I have missed it.

I was going to write a FR on my last punt but I know it will get rejected. This is because it involves the same agency more than 3 times in the last 3 months and therefore breaks the FR rules.

I thought about putting another agency name down with the girl but I'm worried that the FR will get rejected because the agency won't be able to confirm the booking. Basically, I don't want to waste my time typing it out if its not going to be published.

Is the thing to do:

(i) Forget writing the report, keep details to myself

(ii)Post in the Information thread

(iii)write a FR with a different agency name and hope it doesn't get rejected

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Apologies if this has been covered or is stated and I have missed it.

I was going to write a FR on my last punt but I know it will get rejected. This is because it involves the same agency more than 3 times in the last 3 months and therefore breaks the FR rules.

I thought about putting another agency name down with the girl but I'm worried that the FR will get rejected because the agency won't be able to confirm the booking. Basically, I don't want to waste my time typing it out if its not going to be published.

Is the thing to do:

(i) Forget writing the report, keep details to myself

(ii)Post in the Information thread

(iii)write a FR with a different agency name and hope it doesn't get rejected

I would post on the Information Board. Where you say you are worried the FR will get rejected because the Agency wont be able to confirm the booking, confirm the booking to who?:P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I would post on the Information Board. Where you say you are worried the FR will get rejected because the Agency wont be able to confirm the booking, confirm the booking to who?:P

Well some agencies have links to the FR for the girl in question. I don't know how organised they are in cross referencing FRs with bookings that according to the FR were made with them. But I think I catch your drift :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Apologies if this has been covered or is stated and I have missed it.

I was going to write a FR on my last punt but I know it will get rejected. This is because it involves the same agency more than 3 times in the last 3 months and therefore breaks the FR rules.

I thought about putting another agency name down with the girl but I'm worried that the FR will get rejected because the agency won't be able to confirm the booking. Basically, I don't want to waste my time typing it out if its not going to be published.

Is the thing to do:

(i) Forget writing the report, keep details to myself

(ii)Post in the Information thread

(iii)write a FR with a different agency name and hope it doesn't get rejected

I don't think you should lie and put it in under another of the agencies where she works, as part of the FR is for the agency itself. An experience, good or bad, is always partly down to the agency.

Option 2 sounds like the best idea to me, although if is was going to be a positive report then you could always punt with the girl again in a few months and post a report then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Apologies if this has been covered or is stated and I have missed it.

I was going to write a FR on my last punt but I know it will get rejected. This is because it involves the same agency more than 3 times in the last 3 months and therefore breaks the FR rules.

I thought about putting another agency name down with the girl but I'm worried that the FR will get rejected because the agency won't be able to confirm the booking. Basically, I don't want to waste my time typing it out if its not going to be published.

Is the thing to do:

(i) Forget writing the report, keep details to myself

(ii)Post in the Information thread

(iii)write a FR with a different agency name and hope it doesn't get rejected

Why would you even consider doing this? You know its against the rules and by Galahads rules if you do it the AGENCY, not you will be punished. A client did this to a friend of mine because he thought he was being helpfull, the poor girl had no idea until it was too late and he called her to apologies as ALL of her reports had been removed and his account suspended. She is now on the no reports list because the MORON (you know who you are) did just what you are suggesting and tried to ignore the rules.

Do you want the agency to be banned? If the answer is no, do the agency a favour and forget the report, they wont thank you for it if they get banned

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Why would you even consider doing this? You know its against the rules and by Galahads rules if you do it the AGENCY, not you will be punished. A client did this to a friend of mine because he thought he was being helpfull, the poor girl had no idea until it was too late and he called her to apologies as ALL of her reports had been removed and his account suspended. She is now on the no reports list because the MORON (you know who you are) did just what you are suggesting and tried to ignore the rules.

Do you want the agency to be banned? If the answer is no, do the agency a favour and forget the report, they wont thank you for it if they get banned

Thankyou Sasha. I will not be submitting the report as of course I don't want any repercussions for the agency or indeed myself. Consider the matter closed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I want to submit a report on the fact that my escort didn't show at my home. Strange considering all the effort that we both put in to organising it.

She even phoned me to say she would be late and sent a text claiming to be in my car park. 3 days have passed and she has not responded to either my emails or texts asking why the change in mind. However because "no money changed hands" I can't submit the report :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It would be pointess to be able to report on a booking that did not actually happen, its too open to abuse. If a guy booked a lady, she then tried to contact him to say she couldnt make it but he wouldnt answer the tx, wouldnt answer the call etc because he is sitting there with his wife then it is no fault of the girl. It does happen, i have had bookings made on another site, guy no showed then he said that the booking was never made. If guys can report on non events then ladies must be able to report on no show,s including posting the phone number and name the booking was made under, would you like this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It would be pointess to be able to report on a booking that did not actually happen, its too open to abuse. If a guy booked a lady, she then tried to contact him to say she couldnt make it but he wouldnt answer the tx, wouldnt answer the call etc because he is sitting there with his wife then it is no fault of the girl. It does happen, i have had bookings made on another site, guy no showed then he said that the booking was never made. If guys can report on non events then ladies must be able to report on no show,s including posting the phone number and name the booking was made under, would you like this.

I agree totally with chloe on this one. My only neutral feed back on another site is from a man who booked me and then sent a text to cancel right at the last moment. I tried to contact him to see if it was nerves or if he wanted to rearrange etc, but no reply. Next thing I know he is accusing me of being a no show! He did it to someone else as well on the same day.

God knows what is going through some people's minds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(i) Forget writing the report, keep details to myself

(ii)Post in the Information thread

(iii)write a FR with a different agency name and hope it doesn't get rejected

The posting rules are clear and for a reason.

(i) Write and save your report and post after three months from your last report.

(ii) This will get removed as this is for posting "requests for information" if a punter has asked for information then by all means post details, contact, discription, area, services etc but anything that reads like an FR may be deemed as touting or cheerleading.

(iii) Reports will not be accepted if;

"You reported on the lady or party within the past six months"

So if you change the agency it makes no difference, it may even start alarm bells ringing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The posting rules are clear and for a reason.

(i) Write and save your report and post after three months from your last report.

(ii) This will get removed as this is for posting "requests for information" if a punter has asked for information then by all means post details, contact, discription, area, services etc but anything that reads like an FR may be deemed as touting or cheerleading.

(iii) Reports will not be accepted if;

"You reported on the lady or party within the past six months"

So if you change the agency it makes no difference, it may even start alarm bells ringing.

Would it be sensible, or inflammatory, if someone were to start a thread entitled: 'Which ladies have failed to turn up?' because I, for one, would want to know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Would it be sensible, or inflammatory, if someone were to start a thread entitled: 'Which ladies have failed to turn up?'

Good question! I will ask questions later.

I have bought this up in the Mods room.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I understand and appreciate what Chloe has written.

Though at the same time I thought this whole punternet world in the internet ether was to help both working ladies and punters.

The lady didn't show after some fantastic communication by email and phone and she tells me she's outside, so I go out to meet her with a car permit and she's not there. On the day and a couple of days after I left polite voice messages and sent texts and emails to find out why (originally on the day I thought she was lost and in the wrong place) and the lady chose not to reply, even after both of us putting all the effort in. It was not my intention to write a simple two or 3 line report blasting her that she didn't show. As I wrote she was fantastic in all previous communication until the day. I took the day off work, she was late, she phoned to say she was, then she phones to say she's outside but she's not, then she decides to turn off all communication, why am I not allowed to file a report on that?

The thought had actually crossed my mind that she may have had an car accident or that this ex-retired lady may have chosen to retire again, though this morning I see that she has updated her website again and is still working.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
she was late, she phoned to say she was, then she phones to say she's outside but she's not, then she decides to turn off all communication, why am I not allowed to file a report on that?

It is a requirement that money change hands in order for a Field Report to be considered for publication.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I want to submit a report on the fact that my escort didn't show at my home. Strange considering all the effort that we both put in to organising it.

She even phoned me to say she would be late and sent a text claiming to be in my car park. 3 days have passed and she has not responded to either my emails or texts asking why the change in mind. However because "no money changed hands" I can't submit the report :rolleyes:

I agree with Chloe's response to this. You really would not want us printing every no show. I myself failed to turn up for an appointment last night, my reason was simple. First of all he texted, knowing I don't do text bookings. Then he took an hour to respond to me. When he eventually rang and I took his details down I ran a check on him and he failed. He moved out of where he lived 4 years ago despite telling me he lived there!!! Sorry but I am not going to travel to a random house where you might or might not live anymore. If you fail the security check I won't attend simple as that.

The fact that he did not query where I was until 2 hrs after the due time, and then it was only by text made me hear alarm bells. Just some guy trying to get his rocks off.

She may well have pulled in to the car park and saw something she did not like and decide to leave.

It may have been an inconvenience for you, but just think yourself lucky you did not part with the money and have a terrible time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I understand and appreciate what Chloe has written.

Though at the same time I thought this whole punternet world in the internet ether was to help both working ladies and punters.

The lady didn't show after some fantastic communication by email and phone and she tells me she's outside, so I go out to meet her with a car permit and she's not there. On the day and a couple of days after I left polite voice messages and sent texts and emails to find out why (originally on the day I thought she was lost and in the wrong place) and the lady chose not to reply, even after both of us putting all the effort in. It was not my intention to write a simple two or 3 line report blasting her that she didn't show. As I wrote she was fantastic in all previous communication until the day. I took the day off work, she was late, she phoned to say she was, then she phones to say she's outside but she's not, then she decides to turn off all communication, why am I not allowed to file a report on that?

The thought had actually crossed my mind that she may have had an car accident or that this ex-retired lady may have chosen to retire again, though this morning I see that she has updated her website again and is still working.

I have said it myself, its a great disadvantage of the FR system IMO that a punter is unable to submit a FR on such a punt as you describe or where you turn up to find the lady has lied or misled you so you walk before money has changed hands, the rules are clear though. Fortunately forum members can post about their experiences on here.

I even gave a bad provider a £1 last year on my way out after discovering her lies so i could legitimately do a FR, problem was i thought she was going to get violent, she did start shouting so i wont be doing that again.:rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I even gave a bad provider a £1 last year on my way out after discovering her lies so i could legitimately do a FR, problem was i thought she was going to get violent, she did start shouting so i wont be doing that again.:D

You've mentioned this a couple of times on these boards now smiths and I have to say that every time you do, my smile gets broader when I read it. Any chance the incident was caught on CCTV :rolleyes:;):D ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I agree with Chloe's response to this. You really would not want us printing every no show. I myself failed to turn up for an appointment last night, my reason was simple. First of all he texted, knowing I don't do text bookings. Then he took an hour to respond to me. When he eventually rang and I took his details down I ran a check on him and he failed. He moved out of where he lived 4 years ago despite telling me he lived there!!! Sorry but I am not going to travel to a random house where you might or might not live anymore. If you fail the security check I won't attend simple as that.

The fact that he did not query where I was until 2 hrs after the due time, and then it was only by text made me hear alarm bells. Just some guy trying to get his rocks off.

She may well have pulled in to the car park and saw something she did not like and decide to leave.

It may have been an inconvenience for you, but just think yourself lucky you did not part with the money and have a terrible time.

I wouldnt have any problems with ladies printing no shows. A number of times i have arranged a punt on the phone, specifically agreed things and arrived to find one or more things agreed are not actually on offer, leading me to walk. These providers rely on the punter thinking with his dick and punting regardless, they are mercifully rare in my experience but like all bad providers should be exposed for what they really are IMO.:rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You've mentioned this a couple of times on these boards now smiths and I have to say that every time you do, my smile gets broader when I read it. Any chance the incident was caught on CCTV :rolleyes:;) ?

To be honest like a number of scams i have experienced they are amusing after the event and where i had an alternative. Still not on though of course. The £1 incident was a spur of the moment punt just after i had punted with Seductive Scarlet in Hemel, i was still feeling randy, i couldnt extend my punt with her as it was her last of the day so i knew i was going past this providers place and thought why not.

As to being on CCTV i hope not, i would of looked a right wimp the way i literally bolted out of the place.:D:D:D:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Would it be sensible, or inflammatory, if someone were to start a thread entitled: 'Which ladies have failed to turn up?' because I, for one, would want to know.

a) sensible ~ probably not

:D inflammatory ~ probably yes, though that alone shouldn't stop anyone

As Kirsty was maybe implying - maybe she didn't turn up cos you're a knob.

So knowing she didn't turn up for you doesn't help me that much. If 40 people said she didn't turn up, that's different. I'd want to know. But how would you collate stats like that? Feedback on 'the other site' is among the closest you might get.

And even then, I recently emailed a lady who had 40 unread emails (thank you kind Forum Member who showed me how to do this). But I got an email back within twelve hours.

Good reports are logically more robust than negative ones. But especially if they are verifiable. In other words, I can see the ID of the punter and check his previous FRs, his track record on a forum or some other indicator that I can relate to. Negative reports are helpful in the light of many positive ones (the logic takes too long to explain).

Of course, I like to know for myself if a girl has or hasn't turned up. It's nice to know I don't have Alzheimer's yet. :rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've also had a no-show from a lady who was too embarrassed (I can only assume) to admit the paucity of her excuse till a long time afterwards. And she gave good service on every other occasion.

I broadly classify people generally to a large extent on how reliable they are (ie with me!) Sometimes I need reliable. Sometimes I just can enjoy people for their own sake and with their faults. Not everyone is as 'reliable as volkswagen.' :rolleyes:

I think the real complaint must be ladies that are so routinely no-show that they shouldn't advertise as being in business. Or punters who are frequently no-show and should be blacklisted. Such dummies make it harder for the rest of us to meet up in peace and a degree of mutual trust.

But if someone wants to get a no-show (either way) off their chest, just posting it, why not? One advantage of Punternet is that there will almost invariably be someone who can see the 'other side' (even if said punter or WG is undeniably one dimensional).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now