worldpunter

A Free Lunch ?

36 posts in this topic

It is often said there is no such thing as a free lunch....

After being a member on this forum for about a year now and a contributor and avid reader of FR i would like to put it to other members the question of free sex or reduced prices or extra time given in return for positive FR by SP listed on Pnet.

could this be the elephant in the room ?

off the top of my head I can think of 3 SP who are willing to go down this route.

I put it to fellow punters, not to be tempted, and i ask the wg to consider her position also.

A long list of positive FR i would view as suspicious now i am aware of this practice.

I still consider the best and most honest recomendations travel by PM and not on the open boards.

Hope i am not rocking the boat by posting this, any comments ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know what the Punternet standard is... on LBB (Manchester forum) its tolerated as long as reviewer makes it clear he got a discount.

Its not ideal even then... difficult to argue otherwise I think. But to be fair... I can't think of any regular contributor to these boards (or on LBB) whose "word" would be influenced by a few quid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It is often said there is no such thing as a free lunch....

After being a member on this forum for about a year now and a contributor and avid reader of FR i would like to put it to other members the question of free sex or reduced prices or extra time given in return for positive FR by SP listed on Pnet.

could this be the elephant in the room ?

off the top of my head I can think of 3 SP who are willing to go down this route.

I put it to fellow punters, not to be tempted, and i ask the wg to consider her position also.

A long list of positive FR i would view as suspicious now i am aware of this practice.

I still consider the best and most honest recomendations travel by PM and not on the open boards.

Hope i am not rocking the boat by posting this, any comments ?

I must say,I am somewhat surprised at this. Very seldom has any escort I have seen even mentioned a review at all, let alone free this or that !! What has happened is that I have been offered slightly reduced rates should I wish to return but it was not linked to any promise for a review.

ps -- I agree PM system is important for the ' insider ' opinion.!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It is often said there is no such thing as a free lunch....

After being a member on this forum for about a year now and a contributor and avid reader of FR i would like to put it to other members the question of free sex or reduced prices or extra time given in return for positive FR by SP listed on Pnet.

could this be the elephant in the room ?

off the top of my head I can think of 3 SP who are willing to go down this route.

I put it to fellow punters, not to be tempted, and i ask the wg to consider her position also.

A long list of positive FR i would view as suspicious now i am aware of this practice.

I still consider the best and most honest recomendations travel by PM and not on the open boards.

Hope i am not rocking the boat by posting this, any comments ?

The practice of a lady/establishment giving a discount in exchange for a FR, GOOD or BAD is or was allowed, its even been advertised on the Announcement Board, offering a discount for a positive FR is not allowed. Those SPs who do this should be banned if caught in my view, it undermines the FR system and i recall Galahad posting it would result in a ban. I wouldnt be suspicious of a long list of positive FRs on their own, i have found WGs who know about them are in some cases keen to build them up, nothing wrong with that IMO, the great Shanelle of St Albans now well into the top 10 of FRd WGs did ask me if i knew about FRs and said she had found them useful to her business, others have said similar, i neither received or asked for special treatment.

The best recommendations are by PM i agree, and from those i trust or at least respect on the board who do post their recommendations openly on the information board which i thank them for.

Personally i viewed a FR as a moment in time and if i knew the WG was a board member i would mention at the end that i intended to do a FR out of courtesy and knowing she might read a post of mine about the punt.

The only discounts i have had is through being a regular of ladies over the years or on 2+ Hour punts.:eek:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All depends if it is an establishment the I would say no if it is an indi then why not?

If an indi asks for a fr in exchange for a discount return visit then they must have been ok in the first place for them to want to return, if an establishment then they can go back and see another girl so the incentive to write false reviews is there.

I seen it actively encouraged on another site, I have no probs with this.

S x

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think it as much giving a discount for a good FR as the WL giving the punter an extra good time , and providing services which she might not normally do , in exchange for a good FR .

This makes the FR invalid as other punters would be unlikely to get the same treatment .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't think it as much giving a discount for a good FR as the WL giving the punter an extra good time , and providing services which she might not normally do , in exchange for a good FR .

This makes the FR invalid as other punters would be unlikely to get the same treatment .

Thats why the special treatment doesnt get mentioned in the FR or anywhere else if the punter is smart.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I once went for lunch with a WG and she insisted we went Dutch on the meal. Best offer I've ever had

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It is often said there is no such thing as a free lunch....

After being a member on this forum for about a year now and a contributor and avid reader of FR i would like to put it to other members the question of free sex or reduced prices or extra time given in return for positive FR by SP listed on Pnet.

could this be the elephant in the room ?

off the top of my head I can think of 3 SP who are willing to go down this route.

I put it to fellow punters, not to be tempted, and i ask the wg to consider her position also.

A long list of positive FR i would view as suspicious now i am aware of this practice.

I still consider the best and most honest recomendations travel by PM and not on the open boards.

Hope i am not rocking the boat by posting this, any comments ?

I have not been offered anything for a positive report yet. I was however offered "a buy one and get two together" providing I wrote a negative report for her co-worker. On a negative response from me I was told to sod off and put on blocked lists. I don't understand. I thought two negatives create a positive but ....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know of one poster on these boards who has done quite well from a lady by writing a nice FR, and a bit of subtle cheerleading.... And no, I wont name and shame. Girls can be bitchy and I don't need the hassle.

I don't agree with it btw.

ETA: On the same sentiment, punters can use the boards to their advantage by spreading false rumours about girls too... which ain't nice and it ain't pretty!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
After being a member on this forum for about a year now and a contributor and avid reader of FR i would like to put it to other members the question of free sex or reduced prices or extra time given in return for positive FR by SP listed on Pnet.

Sorry but Id never accept free sex in exchange for giving a positive FR.

I get annoyed by the false FRs on there at the moment so dont want to add to the problem..

Additionally, but I feel really uneasy about getting stuff free or "at discount" just because Im on here. I'll do a review if I feel they deserve one, not cos they bribed me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sorry but Id never accept free sex in exchange for giving a positive FR.

I get annoyed by the false FRs on there at the moment so dont want to add to the problem..

Additionally, but I feel really uneasy about getting stuff free or "at discount" just because Im on here. I'll do a review if I feel they deserve one, not cos they bribed me.

Did anyone insinuate that you did hon?

I wonder if some gents actually tell WG's they are "so-and-so" on PN when they get to their booking hoping that the girl makes more of an effort in the hope that they might get an FR???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally I would never ask for nor expect any favours for writing a favourable FR. Doing that totally undermines the entire FR system.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wonder if some gents actually tell WG's they are "so-and-so" on PN when they get to their booking hoping that the girl makes more of an effort in the hope that they might get an FR???

They do. I have had two who soon as they were in the door made it very clear they wrote field reports on PN. I smiled sweetly and said, oh please dont leave me one as I dont want any on there. I quickly made the excuse that I found them tacky.

Ok my statement was not quite true (every girl likes free advertising) but I did not want to feel beholden to them.

I guess it worked to my detriment as well. They have now become regulars and I still have no FR's here so I sort of cut off my own nose but hey ho at least I didnt feel obliged to try to do the whole super porn start act which I am so lousy at.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It is often said there is no such thing as a free lunch....

After being a member on this forum for about a year now and a contributor and avid reader of FR i would like to put it to other members the question of free sex or reduced prices or extra time given in return for positive FR by SP listed on Pnet.

could this be the elephant in the room ?

off the top of my head I can think of 3 SP who are willing to go down this route.

I put it to fellow punters, not to be tempted, and i ask the wg to consider her position also.

A long list of positive FR i would view as suspicious now i am aware of this practice.

I still consider the best and most honest recomendations travel by PM and not on the open boards.

Hope i am not rocking the boat by posting this, any comments ?

Excuse me but i have a decent list of positive FR,s only one NO compared to 38 YES, 3 of my reports have been deleted because the posters have been since banned from the board for various reasons so i actually recieved 41 good reports in the last two years. I have never ever offered discounts for FR,s. You should not assume we are all guilty of the same tactics.x

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Did anyone insinuate that you did hon?

No. But Im answering the question of the OP. :eek:

I wonder if some gents actually tell WG's they are "so-and-so" on PN when they get to their booking hoping that the girl makes more of an effort in the hope that they might get an FR???

I try and keep anonymous as possible. I dont book as Overworked. Ive even asked maids who have twigged out that Im on here NOT to tell the girl Im on here.

The whole point of me punting is Im trying to build up confidence so I can cope better in the real world so I wont be single forever. So I want her to treat me as she sees me and not as someone who could post a FR or a thread on a public forum. If I know shes been given the heads up that Im on here then I dont know if shes treating me as me or giving me special treatmeat.

Id rather she treat me as me rather than someone whose on a forum and can do FRs.

Edited by Overworked
Added smily as first setence sounded harse when it isnt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
They do. I have had two who soon as they were in the door made it very clear they wrote field reports on PN. I smiled sweetly and said, oh please dont leave me one as I dont want any on there. I quickly made the excuse that I found them tacky.

Ok my statement was not quite true (every girl likes free advertising) but I did not want to feel beholden to them.

I guess it worked to my detriment as well. They have now become regulars and I still have no FR's here so I sort of cut off my own nose but hey ho at least I didnt feel obliged to try to do the whole super porn start act which I am so lousy at.

It does happen, Tammy and i had a two girl with a guy months ago, he was dirty, lecherous , had bad teeth, slimey lips and was just generaly not pleasant,everytime one of us moved he was lunging at us and grabbing with curled fingers, he was told not to do this during the booking several times.

We both approached to give a group hug which is where we encountered the lips for the first and only time that appointment and he growled at us "ooo yeah, this is going to make for a great punternet report ladies" needless to say he was not kissed, had covered EVERYTHING and did NOT get anything better or worse than he would have done anyway, no report ever arose and we refused him next time he tried to book by telling him we were fully booked simply because of the grossness of the man, even if he had given us a report we would not have seen him again. I would never give a better service to someone from here, a lot of the guys who post on here do not even do reports, i think most of the reports come from guys who do not. There is nothing wrong with revealing your pnet identity but its best left to the end of the booking unless its been discussed on here already through pm with the guy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A few years go when I was a regular at a certain parlour , I would write a FR when I saw a new girl and post it on the adult board relevant to that area .

I never revealed my board username to them but the girls soon put two and two together and I found that I was getting , what you might call , preferential treatment .

I remember one girl in particular who received a glowing report from me and she later told me that after the FR was published , guys were queuing up to see her .

Subsequent reports followed from guys who had been to see the same girls I had reported on complaining that they did not receive the same treatment as I did .

I only tell you all this to illustrate my point that a FR which is produced with the girls prior knowledge can be very misleading .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wonder if some gents actually tell WG's they are "so-and-so" on PN when they get to their booking hoping that the girl makes more of an effort in the hope that they might get an FR???

They do. I have had two who soon as they were in the door made it very clear they wrote field reports on PN. I smiled sweetly and said, oh please dont leave me one as I dont want any on there. I quickly made the excuse that I found them tacky.

Ok my statement was not quite true (every girl likes free advertising) but I did not want to feel beholden to them.

I guess it worked to my detriment as well. They have now become regulars and I still have no FR's here so I sort of cut off my own nose but hey ho at least I didnt feel obliged to try to do the whole super porn start act which I am so lousy at.

It does happen, Tammy and i had a two girl with a guy months ago, he was dirty, lecherous , had bad teeth, slimey lips and was just generaly not pleasant,everytime one of us moved he was lunging at us and grabbing with curled fingers, he was told not to do this during the booking several times.

We both approached to give a group hug which is where we encountered the lips for the first and only time that appointment and he growled at us "ooo yeah, this is going to make for a great punternet report ladies" needless to say he was not kissed, had covered EVERYTHING and did NOT get anything better or worse than he would have done anyway, no report ever arose and we refused him next time he tried to book by telling him we were fully booked simply because of the grossness of the man, even if he had given us a report we would not have seen him again. I would never give a better service to someone from here, a lot of the guys who post on here do not even do reports, i think most of the reports come from guys who do not. There is nothing wrong with revealing your pnet identity but its best left to the end of the booking unless its been discussed on here already through pm with the guy.

Ooh, what a moral maze :).

Whenever I book a lady who is a regular poster on here, I usually let them know who I am on the forum before hand. It seems the polite thing to do, especially if we've shared some banter on particular threads. I usually find that it helps break the ice a bit to have shared ground in the "getting to know you" phase (not that I want to spend a punt chatting about the stuff that gets written here :)).

It's never even crossed my mind that the lady might think I have let her know my board id simply because I expect better service in return for an FR :eek:. In my case, nothing could be further from the truth.

I guess that when to reveal one's id (if ever) is one of those personal choices that each of us makes and as long as there is nothing underhand planned, it doesn't matter.

I would hope that any lady who felt uncomfortable seeing me based on either my posting style or because I might get into FR bargaining would be upfront about it at the booking stage. I find that getting these things out in the open as early as possible prevent misunderstandings.

Food for thought though.

P.S. As for the OPs question, I would avoid like the plague any scenario whereby future discounts were exchanged for a positive FR. Not only does it inherently devalue the FR system, I seem to remember an esteemed ex-poster on here getting roasted because of such (unproven, as far as I recall) accusations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Northwinds. If someone had approached me via pm then it wouldnt have been a problem. The problem occured as they waited until in the room then instead of dropping into conversation they were members/lurkers one of the first things that was said was "I thought I would tell you I often write FR's on Punternet". To me that was the same as saying be extra nice or else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Northwinds. If someone had approached me via pm then it wouldnt have been a problem. The problem occured as they waited until in the room then instead of dropping into conversation they were members/lurkers one of the first things that was said was "I thought I would tell you I often write FR's on Punternet". To me that was the same as saying be extra nice or else.

Ah, I see. Could still be innocent I suppose (as in the case of your two now regulars). Also, lots of people like to book via phone rather than PM/e-mail. It's often more awkward to introduce the Pnet id on an initial phone chat. Still as you say, it could easily come across as a bit of a pressured intro :eek:.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ETA: On the same sentiment, punters can use the boards to their advantage by spreading false rumours about girls too... which ain't nice and it ain't pretty!

From what i have been told on the board publicly the seedy grapevine of pm,s slateing ladies is alive and kicking. I have been told by someone in a thread that the hatechloe club have been having fun pming each other (and others) about how they would never ever visit an old hag/dragon/hard nosed bitch like me.

Personally i find it amusing but someone with thinner skin would not. The fact that this guy never visits ladies of my age anyway (wouldnt be able to cope with us i believe) is the fact that ensures i couldnt care less.

It is rather amusing though knowing they are spending some of their time doing this, dont they have anything better to do.lol.x:rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It only comes up with me after the punt as, if I fancy doing one, I almost always ask if she minds if I do a report.

When I've seen her again I quite often get a friendlier reception because she liked what I said or that punters tell her they came to see her after reading it.

So that seems win win and nothing underhand to me.

Might be slightly different now we can report more than once on the same wg but the first time I tried it once I understood it was allowed, I was put off by being asked if the same girl/town combination was being reported on and it gave a contact number that just looked something like 2894386 which I didn't recognise as a phone number or an FR number so I abandoned the report for fear of doing something wrong. :eek:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ooh, what a moral maze :).

Whenever I book a lady who is a regular poster on here, I usually let them know who I am on the forum before hand. It seems the polite thing to do, especially if we've shared some banter on particular threads. I usually find that it helps break the ice a bit to have shared ground in the "getting to know you" phase (not that I want to spend a punt chatting about the stuff that gets written here :)).

It's never even crossed my mind that the lady might think I have let her know my board id simply because I expect better service in return for an FR :eek:. In my case, nothing could be further from the truth.

I guess that when to reveal one's id (if ever) is one of those personal choices that each of us makes and as long as there is nothing underhand planned, it doesn't matter.

I would hope that any lady who felt uncomfortable seeing me based on either my posting style or because I might get into FR bargaining would be upfront about it at the booking stage. I find that getting these things out in the open as early as possible prevent misunderstandings.

Food for thought though.

P.S. As for the OPs question, I would avoid like the plague any scenario whereby future discounts were exchanged for a positive FR. Not only does it inherently devalue the FR system, I seem to remember an esteemed ex-poster on here getting roasted because of such (unproven, as far as I recall) accusations.

It does not personally bother me if a guy lets me know before,after or during. Knowing who someone is does lead to some nice banter i agree.

I only say that in most cases its best left to the end because that way the lady cannot be accused of giving preferential treatment to a pnet reporter and the guy can be safe in the knowledge that he recieved fair treatment so can write an honest report knowing it to be true.

Most guys do not use their user nicks to advantage, a small minority do though, some who do are probably not even really on pnet, have just read the board but not joined.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Northwinds. If someone had approached me via pm then it wouldnt have been a problem. The problem occured as they waited until in the room then instead of dropping into conversation they were members/lurkers one of the first things that was said was "I thought I would tell you I often write FR's on Punternet". To me that was the same as saying be extra nice or else.

It can also be a disadvantage for someone who writes mostly bad reports when all they have to complain about are tiny little things such as...

she would not move her leg 2cm to the left

her tan was not of the calibre i expected

i know i only paid 50 for a quickie but for a level, cim, facials and come 3 times etc to be off the menu is just unnacceptable

Ladies in parlours do get to know who is who and if a constant negative reporter turns up to meet the ladies he may find that not many want to say hello.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now